Hawks' Corner

Your place to find links, news, opinion and more from Renton\'s only local Seahawks coverage

Putting criticism of Seneca Wallace to the test

September 24th, 2009 at Thu, 24th, 2009 at 11:16 am by Adam McFadden

It’s getting harder and harder to find people in the national media who believe in Seneca Wallace:

Peter King of Sports Illustrated illustrates exactly large he thinks the gap between Matt Hasselbeck and Wallace is in his Week 3 picks:

I’m not saying Matt Hasselbeck is a candidate for MVP or anything like that. But the dropoff from Hasselbeck to Seneca Wallace is like the dropoff from Peyton Manning to Jim Sorgi.

Adam Schein writes on Foxsports.com:

This is a major boom. I have a ton of respect for the defensive stars on the Seahawks and the 12th-man factor playing in the great northwest. But Matt Hasselbeck broke a rib, and I don’t think Seneca Wallace can get it done.

John Hansen writes the most stinging criticism of Wallace in a Yahoo sports article:

Seahawks QB Seneca Wallace(notes) isn’t an NFL QB; he’s not even a backup. He doesn’t know what he’s seeing. Again, Seattle is in trouble if Matt Hasselbeck(notes) misses a lot of time.

I agree with King that there is a big dropoff from Hasselbeck to Wallace — there’s a reason Hasselbeck is the unquestioned starter when healthy.

Schein’s comments makes enough sense, although with the injuries to Leroy Hill, Marcus Trufant and Lofa Tatupu you wonder how much those defensive stars he mentioned will be a factor.

However Hansen’s comments seem particularly tough to swallow. To say Wallace isn’t even a backup doesn’t really make sense. Wallace has a career quarterback rating of 83.0, which certainly isn’t awe-inspiring, but it’s not terrible.

To keep things local, let’s look at the other NFC West backups. In Arizona, you have Matt Leinart — career QB rating of 71.6. In San Francisco, there is Alex Smith (63.5). And in St. Louis you have Kyle Boller with a career rating of 71.9.

So far I’m not seeing how Wallace is not worthy of being a backup. To further the point, here are the four QBs’ career touchdown to interception ratios: Wallace (23:13), Leinart (14:17), Smith (19:31) and Boller (45:44). Wallace also has the highest career completion percentage out of the four.

I understand Hansen is using his expert eye to dissect how Wallace works on the field, but these aren’t small sample sizes. How much should we weigh Hansen’s scouting acumen over established numbers?

Adam McFadden is the sports writer for the Renton Reporter. Find more news and articles. about high school sports in Renton and the Seahawks

ABOUT COMMUNITY BLOGS: Community blogs are written by volunteers. They are members of our community but not employees of this site or newspaper. They have applied or were invited to blog here but their words are their own and are not edited by the editor or staff of this site, and have agreed to abide by our Terms of Use. The authors are solely responsible for their content. If you have concerns about something you read on a community blog, please contact the author directly or email us.

COMMENTING RULES: We encourage an open exchange of ideas in the PNWLocalNews.com community, but we ask you to follow our guidelines for respecting community standards. In a nutshell, don't say anything you wouldn't want your mother to read.

So keep your comments:

  • Civil
  • Smart
  • On-topic
  • Free of profanity

We ask that all participants own their words by registering for an account. It's a simple process that will take seconds and helps keep our comments free of trolls, cranks, and drive-by commenters.

As a community site, we ask that the community help by using the "Flag" button on each comment if they feel the comment has violated the rules. You can also use the up and down arrows on each comment to voice your opinion about that particular comment.

Want to tell us something but you don't want it to be public? Talk to us privately.

blog comments powered by Disqus